Skip to main content
November 4, 2023
Question

I bought 10 boxes of baseball cards for $35 each. The cost basis for each card is $.34 and there are 990 cards total. If I sell 1 card for $350, do I have tax of $0?

  • November 4, 2023
  • 2 replies
  • 0 views
What about if I sell one card for $350 and sell the others for $1 total, or just throw them away?

Can I offset my $350 sale, or any other sales, by getting rid of other cards that had a cost basis higher than I got rid of them for?

2 replies

DoninGA
Employee
November 4, 2023

Your cost basis is $0.34 per card.  If you sell one card for $350 then you have a capital gain of $349.66.

If you sell any other cards for $1.00 each then you have a capital gain of $.66 per card.

 

If you throw all the other cards away other than the card you sold for $350 you still have a capital gain of $349.66.

rynstrssAuthor
November 4, 2023

Thanks for the reply. What if I sell the other 989 cards for $10 total? In total I would have $360 in sales for a $10 profit by selling them all. 

November 4, 2023

the sale could come under the rules for sale of collectibles, but if it's an activity not engaged in for a profit, it's likely a hobby and the hobby rules say income is taxable, but expenses are not deductible.

 

rynstrssAuthor
November 4, 2023

I purchase cards, and will sell some more rare ones at a profit, but it's hard to sell the common ones. So if I can sell 1000 of them at $10 total, will that offset some of the profit on the 1 expensive card?

DoninGA
Employee
November 4, 2023

Your cost is $350.  Any sales you make that is over $350 is your profit and is taxable.