Type> letme <in the search box. That will take you to a screen where you can select an alternative credit or deduction. Change it back it you don't like the result (and you most likely won't).
$8500 of tuition should have gotten you the maximum $2500 american opportunity credit (AOC).
The tuition and fees deduction (TFD) is only a deduction, not a credit, and is limited to $4000 (and could be only $2000). So, $4000 times your tax bracket (example 12%) = $480. The Lifetime Learning Credit (LLC) is 20% of Tuition; so $8500 x 20% = $1700.
The TFD does also lower your income for state taxes (in most states). So, for example, $4000 x 5% = $200.