Solved
We have joint accounts and two separate logins for the retirement accounts. Can't seem to add another import account
Make sure you have fully completed the 1st entry and are back to the screen that states, Here's your 1099-R info. From here follow these steps:
- Select add another 1099-R
- Select the financial institute
- Login with your second login information
See screenshot below:

Enter your E-mail address. We'll send you an e-mail with instructions to reset your password.