Solved
I live in Ohio if that makes any difference. I tried adding a locality and doing it on a separate W2 neither option worked and it won't let me file.
You can add the local taxes together and make one entry. The state will have a copy of your W-2 forms and the taxes paid in as reported on them. As long as the taxes reported on your tax return for the locality matches the total paid in as reported on your W-2 forms, the taxing authority will be able to match them as the totals will agree.
Enter your E-mail address. We'll send you an e-mail with instructions to reset your password.