Signon bonus repayment taxes witheld
Hi Community,
I received a signon bonus from a company I joined in 2021 but I left the company this year and had to pay back a portion of the signon bonus pro-rated. The company issued me an updated W2-C for the difference in the amount I returned back reflected in the wages box (1). However, the W2-C also shows updated taxes withheld which is lower than than the amount that were actually withheld in 2021. I checked with the company and they say that the difference in taxes withheld is correct as that amount is claimed by the company as I never received the full amount (because I returned back a portion of the signon bonus). This part is confusing to me, as I feel that the taxes on the original amount were already paid and since I returned a portion of the signon bonus, I should be able to get the difference in taxes withheld as return.
Can someone shed light on how to handle this situation? If I enter the updated W2-C values, I don't see a difference in the return amount in Turbotax.