Skip to main content
Employee
April 9, 2019
Question

Withdrew Excess 401k Contribution in 2019, No 1099-R for 2018 Taxes

  • April 9, 2019
  • 1 reply
  • 0 views

Its March 2019 and I am working on my 2018 taxes and realized that I over-contributed on my 401k contribution by $900. 

 

1) I reached out to my 401k plan administrator and had them withdrawal the excess + Earnings from my Roth IRA (I had left the company and rolled over my 401k roth into my roth IRA and 401k to my Traditional IRA. I decided to withdraw the excess from my Roth account). I was told I will not be getting a 1099-R until end of 2019

2) Received confirmation that my withdrawal was successful, in March 2019. $900 excess + $117.43 earnings.

 

Based upon the various answers on Turbot Tax. 

 

1) Do I report this excess under Misc Income with the steps below?

  1. Go to Wages & Income -> Less Common Income -> Miscellaneous Income, 1099-A, 1099-C.
  2. Click Other income not already reported on a Form W-2 or Form 1099.
  3. Answer Yes, you received other wages.
  4. Proceed to the Any Other Earned Income page and answer Yes.
  5. click past next 2 screens till you reach the excess salary deferral screen
  6. Did you earn any other wages answer YES
  7. Choose "OTHER"
  8.  "Excess 401k salary deferral" in the description and enter the amount including earnings that were withdrawn

2) What number do I report? The principle excess, $900 or both principle + earnings, $1017.43?

 

Thank you,

 

1 reply

macuser_22
Employee
April 9, 2019

$900.    The excess 2018 contribution is taxable as wages in 2018 since it is a 2018 contribution, but the earnings returned in 2019 will be 2019 income and you should receive two 2019 1099-R's (in Jan 2020), one with a code P in box 7  for the 2018 taxable (contribution) amount, that you can ignore if you report it now as you are doing, and one with a code 8 for the earnings ($117.43) that is taxable in the year returned.

 

Reporting it now by the method you described prevents having to amend 2018 when the 1099-R arrives.

**Disclaimer: This post is for discussion purposes only and is NOT tax advice. The author takes no responsibility for the accuracy of any information in this post.**