I am facing the same situation. i.e adding rental expenses (taxes, property manager fees, repairs...) INCREASE my FEDERAL TAXES.
Even if this is true, is it legal not to report expenses? I can still report all the rental income, but what if I do not report all the related rental expenses. (if that saves me federal taxes).
I'm glad someone else is having this issue. I find the previous response from the "tax expert" unsatisfactory. Even if she is correct, the explanation is poor. Why does reducing AGI increase tax liability?
I believe tax law does require you to report all of your eligible expenses. But I am not an expert, you should do your own research to be sure.