Skip to main content
April 2, 2025
Question

Traditional to Roth IRA Conversion shows erroneous Excess contribution

  • April 2, 2025
  • 1 reply
  • 0 views

TurboTax 2024 Premier Desktop

In 2024, I converted about $200,000 from Traditional IRA to Roth. Forms 5498 and 1099R were filled out.

Distribution code on Line 7 (1099) shows 7. IRA/SEP/Simple is checked.

Using TurboTax Premier, it calculates (Form 5329-T) that I have about $190,000 of excess contributions.

I am then penalized 6% more in taxation on that excess in the T-Tax calculations.

This should not be characterized as excess contribution since it was a Conversion from Traditional to Roth.

I am old enough that RMD's are required on the Traditional IRA, if that makes any difference in these rules.

    1 reply

    VolvoGirl
    Employee
    April 2, 2025

    Only enter it from the 1099R.  Nowhere else.  Not under deductions as a contribution.  It is not a new contribution.  

    RowbearsAuthor
    April 2, 2025

    Ok. It is in the IRA Contributions Worksheet, Line 19. And the wording there does say not to put in any conversions. So, why is TurboTax automatically populating that line?

     

    VolvoGirl
    Employee
    April 2, 2025

    The only way would be if you entered it under Deductions & Credits for IRA contributions.   Go back and delete it from there.

    Federal

    Deductions and Credits

    Then scroll down to Retirement and Investments

    Traditional and ROTH IRA Contributions - Click the Start or Update button


    You might need to delete the 1099R and
    enter it again Manually (especially if you imported it).